Study shows high level of potentially toxic air pollution in DISH

COMMENT: This is the second article from Fort Worth we've posted recently. Three days ago, it was about Quicksilver Resources, a Texan company, and its stunningly productive new well from the Horn River shales in northeast BC.

Texas & BC, the Barnett shale and BC's Horn River and Montney shale plays.

This article is about pollution from the compression and processing facilities which handle the gas from the Barnett shale.

Hello. Little observed fact: all the gas in northeast BC also needs to be compressed and processed. Don't think it doesn't emit the same nasty stuff that is reported in this study from Texas.

Encana is building the huge Cabin Gas Plant in 60 km northeast of Fort Nelson. The first phase alone, twice the size of the largest gas processing facility in the province, is estimated to cost $400 - $500 million and will process 400 million cubic feet per day (BC's total production is about three times that, and we're already producing 600 mcf from shale). At full build-out the plant will handle 800 mcf daily.

But heck, the provincial government has no monitoring capability, and has no desire to obstruct or deter the big gas investment. Out of sight, out of mind. Animals of other species might suffer the toxic consequences.

And the greenhouse gas emissions? Well, they'll just be vented - all 2 million plus tonnes per year. If suitable nearby disposal areas are proven up, and IF suitable federal and provincial subsidies are made available, the company may be able to sequester and reinject the CO2 (and the H2S) from the plant. Otherwise? It becomes the biggest single source of greenhouse has emissions in the province.

So pay some attention to this report from Texas where a heck of a lot more people live near the Barnett shale plays. If this is what industry gets away with there, just think of what it can get away with 60 km northeast of Fort Nelson.

As to who is paying attention, the answer is virtually no-one - other than government and industry. The public comment period on the Environmental Assessment expired on August 21. Four, that's FOUR, comments were received. Ignace Burke made the point that he and his family live only 5 km from the plant site, but that "nobody mentions that to you people." Karen Campbell and Matt Horne of Pembina Institute submitted the only substantial comment, demanding in effect that all carbon emissions be sequestered and that the downstream carbon emissions from end-use of the gas also be attributed to the project. Yea. Nice try. Fat chance.

This is not an accusation, but it has been proved countless times that the government will not serve as a watchdog for citizens, so citizen watchdogs are essential to protection of our health, our communities, and our environment. What can we do where the citizen watchdogs are non-existent, or unable to take on the work?

Project site at the Environmental Assessment Office

See also:
Gas plant must curb emissions, watchdog says
Multibillion-dollar gas plant planned in B.C.
Huge gas project set for 2011

Curious about the unusual spelling - all capitals - of DISH?

Wikipedia says:

DISH is a town in Denton County, Texas, United States. The town had an estimated population of 181 as of July 1, 2008, according to the United States Census Bureau. Formerly called Clark, the town was officially renamed DISH (all capital letters) on November 16, 2005.

The municipality was previously named after its founder, Landis Clark, who incorporated it in June 2000 and served as its first mayor. Clark was beaten by one vote in the Spring 2005 election by Bill Merritt.

In exchange for renaming the town, all residents of the town have received free basic television service for ten years and a free DVR from DISH Network. There was no formal opposition to renaming Clark; twelve citizens attended the council meeting to support the measure.

Dish Network Corporation is a direct broadcast satellite service provider that ... serves approximately 13.58 million subscribers.

Imagine that. Are you ready for Encana BC?

By MIKE LEE
Star-Telegram (Fort Worth)
Saturday, Sep. 26, 2009

A new study shows high level of potentially harmful air pollution in the town of DISH in Denton County.

DISH sits next to several large compressor stations, which process natural gas from the Barnett Shale and pressurize it for shipment across the country. Residents have complained for years about the smell and the noise.

The study, done by Wolf Eagle Environmental and paid for by the Town Council, found high levels of 15 chemicals, including benzene, xylene, naphthalene and carbon disulfide at five of seven test sites. In some cases the levels were 10 times the recommended level for short-term exposure, and some levels were high enough to be an immediate danger, according to the study. It said, however, that the results were only a one-time snapshot.

Mayor Calvin Tillman, who has been fighting the pipeline companies for about a year, said the study proves that state regulators need to take action.

"I don’t believe this was a one-day event," he said. And even if it was, "you still broke some thresholds for short-term exposure to these chemicals."

Terry Clawson, a spokesman for the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, said the agency was already planning testing for airborne toxins in Denton County.

The companies that run the compressor stations, including Atmos Energy, Chesapeake Energy, Enbridge, Energy Transfer Partners and Crosstex Energy, paid for a study in DISH this year that concluded that gas levels in the air weren’t high enough to be dangerous.

However, that study didn’t check for toxic chemicals, said Scott McLAren of Apogee Scientific, who conducted the survey.

"We were only looking for leaks in natural gas pipelines," he said.

Still, two of the companies referred to the previous study when asked about the latest study.

"We believe we’ve taken ample steps to communicate the details of our investigation to the mayor and will continue to monitor our operations in the area," said Jill McMillan of Crosstex Energy.

Justin Bond of Chesapeake Energy said, "The last time several operators spoke with Mayor Tillman and presented this information, he complimented our efforts."

Mike Lee, 817-390-7539, mikelee@star-telegram.com

Read the DISH, Texas, air study (pdf)

Source

Posted by Arthur Caldicott on 27 Sep 2009